So which type of roof should you get? There are many options when it comes to your roof system, each with its own unique set of benefits. Let’s dive into the pros and cons of the four most common roof systems in the Midwest.
Shingle Roofs
Whether it’s asphalt shingles or synthetic shakes, the shingle roof has stood the test of time in popularity for residential roofing systems. Apart from their traditional appearance, many people are also drawn to shingle roofs for their affordability, effectiveness against the elements, and ease of installation. They are by far the most popular roof selection. Here’s why:
1. Affordability
When it comes to cost, you can’t do better than a shingle roof. As the most economical roof system, shingle roofs attract many clients of ours primarily for their affordability. Despite their modest price, shingle roofs are incredibly cost-effective, boldly standing up against Mother Nature and all of her weather extremes.
2. Attractive Aesthetic
Furthermore, shingle roofs are also considered by many to be the most attractive of roofing systems. With a wide array of colors, styles, and brands to choose from, the possibilities are endless when it comes to creating your unique aesthetic with a shingle roof. The most popular among Weather Stop Roofing‘s customers are dimensional shingles because they provide texture and contrast far superior than the 3-tab shingle.
3. Expanding Lifespan
In terms of lifespan, shingle roofs are about average. Over time, shingles will inevitably succumb to the natural wear and tear caused by exposure to the elements and become less effective. Shingle roofs can last anywhere between 15 and 30 years, with each manufacturer offering their own product warranty based on life expectancy. Some manufacturers are even coming out with longer warranty periods, boasting innovation which enables shingles to withstand the elements for up to 50 years! The warranty period will depend upon the type of shingle you choose. In addition, Weather Stop Roofing offers a Lifetime Material Installer’s Water-Tight Warranty for all roof replacements, guaranteed for the life of your new roof. Choosing the right shingle can have a profound impact on your roof’s lifespan.
4. Ease of Installation
As far as installation goes, shingle roofs are the quickest and easiest. Due to their inherent design, Weather Stop Roofing‘s expert technicians can install a quality new shingle roof within a day or two depending on the size and scope of the project.
5. Simple Repairs
Repairs tend to be relatively simple and affordable if done so proactively. However, one can anticipate a higher likelihood of repairs for a shingle roof as compared to other roofing systems due to their shorter lifespan and greater vulnerability to wear and tear from the elements. That being said, another great benefit of shingle roofs is that individual shingles can be replaced. If your roof suffers isolated damage, Weather Stop Roofing can repair or replace the damaged shingles as opposed to an entire section of your roof as may be required with other roof types.
Metal Roofs
Metal roofs are trendy and possess a clean, modern look. Apart from their attractive aesthetic, these roofs are arguably the best in terms of durability. With the longest expected lifespan of any roof system, metal roofs continue battling the elements for up to 70 years! This is because they are made from materials which will withstand the normal wear and tear seen in the more traditional shingle roofs. Metal roofs are growing in popularity. Here’s why:
1. Two Quality Metal Roof Options
There are two primary options when it comes to metal roofs. We are happy to discuss the details of both with you, but it ultimately comes down to your aesthetic preference and budget. You can read more about metal roofs by visiting our metal roofing services page.
Exposed Fastener
Exposed fastener style metal roof systems are secured to the roof decking with screws through the panels themselves. The screw heads are visible when looking at the roof. Since this installation process is less technical, quicker, and does not require as many materials, it is the less expensive of the two options.
Hidden Fastener
Hidden fastener style metal roof systems use clips to secure the panels to the roof, so there are no punctures in the metal. The clips attach on the under-side of the panels so they are not visible. Since this installation is more labor intensive and requires more materials, it is the more expensive of the two options.
2. Different Gauges
You can choose different gauges (thicknesses) based on your budget and desired durability. The most common are 24-gauge, 26-gauge, and 28-gauge metal panels. As a rule of thumb, the thicker the gauge, the more durable the roof and the higher the cost. Weather Stop Roofing‘s experts will help you determine which gauge is best for your roof based on your desired durability, aesthetic, and budget.
3. Color Variety
Metal roofs come in a variety of colors and styles, ranging from clean and simple neutrals to more architectural and colorful. We are happy to direct you to inventories of our preferred material manufacturers who provide the highest quality metal roofing systems in the industry.
4. Metal Roofs are a Long Term Investment
Many clients of ours are hesitant about the expense of a metal roof. It’s true that you will pay more upfront for this type of roof system. However, it is also true that you will pay less in the long run with a metal roof because they are basically maintenance-free and last significantly longer than any other roofing system. When you install a metal roof, you are making a long-term investment for your home or business as they are arguably the most durable type of roof.
5. Rust and Erosion Resistance
Metal roofs used to be more susceptible to rust and corrosion due to their material make-up. However, metal roofing paint finishes have come a long way. Weather Stop Roofing‘s preferred metal material manufacturers offer paint finishes which serve to prevent corrosion over time. These paint finishes typically come with 45-50 year warranties. Choosing the best materials upfront and being proactive with repairs and storm damage restoration is the best way to prevent wear and tear from affecting the integrity of your metal roof.
Rubber Membrane (EPDM) Roofs
Rubber roofs, also called EPDM, are predominately used on flat or low-sloped commercial roofs. However, they are also the go-to roofing system for flat or low-sloped sections on residential roofs. The rubber membrane section can be tied into a shingle or metal section of your roof. Rubber membranes are a popular choice for flat roofs. Here’s why:
1. Environmentally Friendly
Some individuals are drawn to rubber roofs because they can be environmentally friendly. The rubber membrane is often made from recycled materials and can be used again following a tear-off, making them an excellent choice for those wanting to be more environmentally conscious.
2. Most Effective System for Low-Slope Roofs
Since they have the shortest overall lifespan of all roofing systems (around 20 years) rubber roofs are typically only installed when another roofing system, such as shingles, would not be affective in a low-sloped area. That being said, when it comes to low-slope and flat roofs, you can’t do better than rubber.
Potential Drawbacks
As with all roof systems, there are some potential drawbacks to note when considering a rubber roof.
1. Hold Extra Weight
Firstly, because they typically sit flat or at very gradual slopes, rubber roofs tend to hold water, snow, and debris as opposed to shedding them. This extra weight held by the membrane poses the risk of it suffering damage which may not be as big of a concern with steeper-sloped roofs.
2. Risk of Tearing
Secondly, while it is not a common issue, rubber membranes do have the possibility of tearing. The membranes come in different mills (thicknesses) – typically 45, 60, and up according to the application. Depending on their thickness, some membranes may be more or less likely to experience a tear. Luckily, this sort of damage is very easy to repair. Should you notice a tear in the membrane, Weather Stop Roofing will restore it quickly and affordably as compared to other more extensive roof repairs.
3. Technical Installation
Rubber roofs require a more technical installation process. Weather Stop Roofing‘s skilled technicians are highly efficient and knowledgeable about rubber roof installation, but given its inherent nature, you will be looking at a longer installation period than, say, a shingle roof. Furthermore, rubber roofs are more difficult to install during the winter months because they require a certain level of pliability for installation. For this reason, they are typically only installed when the weather is optimal for the material in the spring, summer, and fall, and on rare occasions during fair weather periods during the winter months.
TPO Roofs
TPO (thermoplastic polyolefin) roofs are single-ply, low-sloped roof systems. They are an excellent choice for homes and businesses with low-sloped or flat roofs due to their incredible durability as compared to other low-sloped roof systems, being especially resistant to tears, punctures, and expansion. They come in a variety of thicknesses which can be selected based on the amount of impact resistance you prefer. TPO roofs are gaining popularity for low-slope roofs. Here’s why:
1. Impressive Lifespan
With a current life-expectancy of 20-30 years, TPO will typically protect against the elements as long as or longer than a shingle roof with much less maintenance. Since TPO roofs are a fairly new product, developed in 1986, they are constantly being improved, and could see an extension in lifespan in the future.
2. Environmentally Friendly
TPO is even more environmentally friendly than EPDM. It reflects UV radiation, which can help cut cooling costs. It is also water-resistant, making it highly effective at preventing mold, moss, and algae growth. They are the best choice for flat or low-sloped restaurant roofs, as grease and oil interact poorly with rubber roofs.
3. Quick and Easy Installation
Although TPO installation is more technical than other systems, it is a relatively quick and easy process. It is incredibly flexible and low-weight at 40lbs per square. Furthermore, due to their temperature resistance, TPO roofs can easily be installed year-round.
4. Efficient Shedding Capabilities
TPO can become very slippery when wet which, while a plus for shedding snow and water, can make it dangerous. To ensure your safety, always recruit a professional to get on your roof. If you notice any damage, Weather Stop Roofing will conduct a free inspection and make any necessary repairs safely and efficiently.
Drawbacks of TPO
For all the advantages of a TPO roof system, you will be paying more upfront. However, the cost of installation is made up in the low cost of maintenance long-term. While infrequent, when repairs are necessary they tend to cost more than other roof systems due to the technicality of repairs and thus the need for professional labor.
Conclusion
The type of roof you choose will depend on a variety of factors, including your budget, aesthetic, durability needs, and the slope of your roof. If you’re looking for an affordable roof with both high durability and unique style options, a shingle roof is the way to go. A metal roof will get you a lifetime of protection, and is a long term investment in your home. Rubber and TPO roofs are your go-to’s for low-slope and flat roofs. Whatever roof system you choose, Weather Stop Roofing will bring quality workmanship and expertise to the jobsite to provide you with a beautiful and durable finished product.
Blog by Weather Stop Roofing
